How to Deal with Music Reading Complainers

Let’s face it; piano music reading is like reading two languages at the same time. There’s going to be times when the brain gets confused. What can a teacher do to help a student not get frustrated?

Have a Coping Strategy for Music Reading

It sure helps the student when he can go to a strategy to unkink a muddled mind – when the treble interferes with the bass-thinking mind – and the reverse situation. The first thing I do is give praise. Here’s an example:

The student has been playing correctly but then come’s to a third line note in the bass and plays “B”. I would say, yes that is B in the treble, but you’re in the bass. Think of the bass spaces. The student says “A-C”. I continue, “And after C comes D – the bass third line is D.”

The student recognizes the note B is wrong – it sounds wrong – but is stuck thinking in the wrong clef and is frustrated. Hearing teacher-praise for having learned B in the treble usually creates calm and a teachable attitude.


Reorient: Go to the Spaces

best beginner piano books

As an orientation thinking process that will need to be relied on for the beginner student, use the spaces of each staff as a starting point.

For the right hand treble staff: F-A-C-E

music reading

For the left hand bass staff: All-Cows-Eat-Grass

In music reading, do you want that smelly cow on top of your FACE? No, it goes on the bottom – in the left hand. FACE goes on top – in the right hand.

Thinking Process: Start with the space/s you know.

Then use the spaces to find the line. For example: A – C, after C comes D.

There’s no need to memorize a clue to remember the line letters. They will come naturely with time if spaces are used to identify (and locate) them.


Having a Strategy Empowers

When the student has learned to go to the strategy for music reading, he/she should feel empowered with a “I can fix it myself” attitude. Now there is no reason to complain or feel inadequate. Teachers can reinforce: “Reading and playing two different languages at the same time – that’s incredible! It’s like patting your head and rubbing your tummy at the same time, but only harder! Get mom or dad to do that and tell them what you’re doing when you play this song! They’ll be impressed!”

It helps to point this out to music reading adult students who feel the occasional frustration when the two clef learnings interfere with each other: “Two languages together at the same time? (I like to use German for the G clef treble and French for the F clef bass.) No wonder you have to stop and think sometimes! I can tell you it won’t always be like that. The two languages will just become the “language of music” to your mind. But until then, refer back to the spaces to find the lines.


To Review: Don’t Use Shortcuts at the Beginning

Yes, the first piano reading exercises are easy to play, but verbally attaching a letter name to a piano key and its line or space on the staff – and moving forward and backward within the alphabet – is much more difficult. Skipping the identification process will cause frustration quickly when hands are combined since learning never concretely took place with each hand’s staff in the beginning. The student must not use shortcuts in the thinking process; such as, “I see a neighbor note comes next so I won’t bother to think of and say the letter name.” However, the teacher should point out that the student won’t have to say letters aloud forever – and will soon be playing without thinking of letter names at all!

If the student was faithful in saying aloud letter names and correctly locating each on the keyboard, he will still have some moments when the brain stalls during music reading. Doing any two things simultaneously can be tricky.  When stalling occurs, have the student choose one hand first, identify and locate the correct note (using space to find line strategy), and then repeat the thinking process with the other hand – and then only afterwards – play hands together. Breaking the process into steps really works!

piano book for beginners

When the teacher reminds the student to use this coping strategy for music reading, it will prevent overwhelming frustration and produce a can-do attitude in the student. Students are happy when they can use a thinking process to find their note names and keys!


Comments are closed.