Instructional Design in Piano Lessons: Part 2 Intensifying Successful Teaching
As discussed earlier, Instructional Design in piano lessons encompasses more than the one focus of student sequential learning through logical, well-planned and incremental portions of the material introduced.
Conscious Practicing
As the heading suggests, conscious practicing is much more than just practicing for a set number of minutes. In conscious practicing, you are fully aware of the task, sensation-sensitive in hearing and touching, and fully and actively engaged.
This makes me think of how I do NOT wrap a present. I know people who really take a long time to conscious-wrap perfect gifts; they measure, crease corners carefully, add tape that’s perfectly horizontal, and top it all off with the perfect ribbon. I prefer the gift bag and a crunch of colored tissue paper on top – that’s my style!
I have students who practice piano like I wrap presents – and it sure shows. I have a few who are model conscious practicers – and it’s very apparent! It’s like they have practiced – not only for a long time during the week – but very carefully to details. So what specifically makes conscious practice?
Ideas for Conscious Practicing
- Start Slowly: When sight-reading a new piece, start slowly – not aiming for the optimal performance tempo yet.
- Read Accurately: Make sure notes are read accurately, and if not, repeat the note/s or measure until they are. Racing through the entire piece will accomplish little except take up practice time.
- Repeat for Success: Continue playing slowly and accurately, repeating flawed areas until they are correct. Repeating errors reinforces errors. Repeat correctly multiple times, slowly then more quickly to attain muscle memory – which won’t occur during just the first practice session.
- Aim for Perfection: Work on every technical issue until they are not issues of error. You may not yet have achieved it, but you’re getting closer to playing perfectly!
- Increase Tempo: Then during the next practice (if appropriate) increase tempo to approach the correct level. This will probably take multiple sessions to arrive at performance tempo that is satisfactory.
The Conscious-Practice Teacher
To encourage the best practice habits for the student, the teacher
- instructs
- demonstrates
- observes the student’s duplication
- makes needed corrections and adjustments
- encourages repetition until the desired outcome is accurately produced by the student
For simple errors, such as a missed flat required by the key signature, if the teacher will call out a prompt (“Key signature!”) as opposed to simply stating the correct note name (“That’s a B flat!”), then the student will have an opportunity to think about and consider the error (“What’s in the key signature? Oh, I have a B flat to remember!”). Being given the opportunity to think about and self-correct the error will make it less likely to occur again, or at least more quickly corrected.
This conscious self-correcting approach can also be encouraged by the teacher’s reminding of using spaces to find the line note – rather than immediately stating the correct letter. Doing this reinforces the Instructional Design approach that fosters self-correction through a cognitive process of thinking through the “known” to correct the “unknown/error.”
This is like the old adage: Give a man a fish, and you have fed him. Teach a man how to fish, and he can feed himself forever.
The conscious teacher
gives the student the tools to correct his own errors
and make self-improvements when alone.




